Order Only - Private message to 12G
May. 10th, 2015 05:07 pmCan we please transfer my mother to Saltash?
Or - all right, perhaps not that. But is there really any reason for her to have her journal? What purpose is served in having her write to Barty Crouch Jr. about who-knows-what? She seems to believe that her writing to Barty "helps me," though I fail to see how it possibly could. If I ever have to cross wands with Crouch, he'll not hesitate to kill me, given that he murdered his own wife. Mother's delusional if she really believes that Barty will be able to protect Hydra, if it came down to that.
And as for her façade of not having turned against the Protectorate, and cloistered herself away merely to keep Bellatrix out - what exactly is to be gained by such antics? In what way does having her carry on in the journals as loyal benefit us? It's not as if Crouch will let any important intel slip out. Hydra's around him all the time and she still hasn't legilimised anything good out of him.
Most likely she just can't stand the thought of being known for having a traitor son, and fears guilt-by-association.
Or - all right, perhaps not that. But is there really any reason for her to have her journal? What purpose is served in having her write to Barty Crouch Jr. about who-knows-what? She seems to believe that her writing to Barty "helps me," though I fail to see how it possibly could. If I ever have to cross wands with Crouch, he'll not hesitate to kill me, given that he murdered his own wife. Mother's delusional if she really believes that Barty will be able to protect Hydra, if it came down to that.
And as for her façade of not having turned against the Protectorate, and cloistered herself away merely to keep Bellatrix out - what exactly is to be gained by such antics? In what way does having her carry on in the journals as loyal benefit us? It's not as if Crouch will let any important intel slip out. Hydra's around him all the time and she still hasn't legilimised anything good out of him.
Most likely she just can't stand the thought of being known for having a traitor son, and fears guilt-by-association.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-10 11:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2015-05-10 11:41 pm (UTC)But one can guess that it was some form of consolation. Entirely unnecessary. If I ever kill someone again, please don't comfort me.
no subject
Date: 2015-05-11 12:05 am (UTC)I agree that it is unlikely she will escape sanction, given how events have happened, should she ever leave the boundaries of the Fidelius. That alone may help to convince her.
Private Message to Mr Snape
Date: 2015-05-11 12:19 am (UTC)I'm not sure what you'd be trying to convince her about, but he did admit that she told him, she's completely aware that her life as she knew it is over.
He's always hated Crouch. I think he's just upset because she spoke to him at all, after he murdered Daphne.
I mean. He's not wrong. But it's not her fault if she still feels some empathy for Crouch.
Re: Private Message to Mr Snape
Date: 2015-05-11 12:25 am (UTC)I think it's best to just let him have his rant. If we're really worried, we can ask to see what she wrote, I suppose.
Re: Private Message to Mr Snape
Date: 2015-05-11 12:29 am (UTC)I understood that Narcissa remained at Malfoy Manor both because she refused to entertain the thought of withdrawing to Saltash, and because we did not wish to burden Saltash with the prospect of accepting another prisoner. It would make no sense to begin the negotiations with Saltash about whether they would accept her if she would refuse to go.
It is understandable that Draco has drawn a bright line in this matter. He can be unforgiving of what he sees as weakness, and it is all too easy for him to view emotion as weakness.